Friday, July 29, 2011

Roberto Alomar - One of the Best

On July 31, 2011, Roberto Alomar's #12 became the first jersey ever retired by the Toronto Blue Jays aside from Jackie Robinson's #42 which has been retired by every Major League team. The previous week, he was the first player inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame wearing a Blue Jays cap. Inevitably these accolades have brought up the argument of whether Roberto Alomar - Robbie as he is affectionately known - can be considered the greatest Blue Jay of all-time despite only playing five seasons in Toronto. However, the term "greatest" is quite subjective when it comes to teams accolades. Does the greatest player on a team mean that most talented or the most influential? Does the greatness have to peak with one team over an extended period of time? Surprisingly the debate over whether Alomar is the greatest second baseman of all-time is more objective and thus easier to settle, so let's deal with that first.

If I could build the perfect second baseman, I do not think I would stray far from Roberto Alomar: a switch-hitter that hit for average, with above-average power and speed who is arguably the best defensive player of his position.

Over his career, Alomar made 12 straight All-Star appearances for four different teams, batted over .300 nine times (1992-1997, 1998-2001), stole over 30 bases eight times (1989, 1991–1993, 1995, 1999–2001), and scored over 100 runs six times (1992–1993, 1996, 1999–2001). In the latter part of his career, Alomar became more of a power threat while maintaining his high batting average and baserunning ability. In 1999, Alomar hit .323 with 24 home runs, 120 RBIs, and 37 stolen bases on 43 attempts. In 2001, he hit .336 with 20 home runs, 100 RBIs, and 30 stolen bases on 36 attempts. Alomar's four Silver Sluggers (1992, 1996, 1999, 2000) is second only to Ryne Sanberg (seven) among second basemen. In 2004, Alomar retired with a career batting average of .300, 2,724 hits, 210 home runs and 1,134 runs  batted in in 2,379 games. 

Defensively, his uncanny range, rocket arm and creative flair resulted in some of the greatest defensive plays from any second baseman in history. Alomar won 10 Gold Gloves from 1991-2001 with 1997 being the only season during that stretch that Alomar was not named the American League's best defensive second-baseman. His 10 Gold Gloves are more than Ryne Sandberg's 9 and Joe Morgan's 5. 
The competition for best second baseman in league history is clearly between Alomar, Ryne Sandberg and Joe Morgan. While Alomar may not have been as valuable for his team as Morgan was to the Big Red Machine, his abilities overweigh Morgan's in every aspect except for speed. Sandberg was Alomar's contemporary in the National League but he was only able to lead the Chicago Cubs to two postseason births. While there is no clear consensus agreement among which of the three was better, a very strong case can be made for Alomar based on physical talent and his integral role on two World Series champions.

Which brings us back to the main issue: What is greatness to a team? In terms of individual accolades there's no question that Roger Clemens' back-to-back Cy Young Awards in 1997 and 1998 - his only seasons with the Blue Jays - are the most impressive. In 1997 Clemens went 21-7 with a 2.05 ERA and led the league in innings pitched (264.0) and strikeouts (292). In terms of longevity, Dave Steib's 15 seasons with the Jays - all but one season of his career - will forever enshrine him in Blue Jays lore. In terms of greatness over an extended period of time, Roy Halladay's 12 seasons with the Blue Jays - eight of which he was arguably the best pitcher in baseball - are fondly remembered for his brilliance on mediocre Blue Jay teams. The 1992 and 1993 World Series teams had an abundance of stars from John Olerud to Duane Ward but none more prominent than Roberto Alomar and Joe Carter. 
Alomar was traded to the Toronto Blue Jays before the 1991 season along with Joe Carter for Tony Fernandez and Fred McGriff. This trade, aside from being one of the league's biggest blockbuster trades with four stars being exchanged, is perhaps the most important in Blue Jays history as both Alomar and Carter played significant roles in bringing the World Series championship to Toronto in 1992 and 1993. Alomar was entering the prime of his career while Carter was in the tailend of his.
Alomar homer in Game 4 was a no-doubter.
In the 1992 ALCS against Oakland, Alomar batted .423 with an OPS of 1.157. He will forever be remembered for his game tying, 9th inning home run off of reigning AL MVP and Cy Young Winner Dennis Eckersley in Game 4. With Devon White on third and the Jays down two, Alomar hit a 2-2 fastball from Eckersley into the right-field stands and immediately pointed his fingers in the air. The Jays would go on to win Game 4 in 11 innings and Alomar would be named the 1992 ALCS MVP. While Joe Carter's iconic home run to win the 1993 World Series may be the most memorable play in Blue Jays history, Alomar's home run off Eckersley may be the most important and is widely considered the turning point where the Toronto Blue Jays began to believe that they could win the World Series, after years of disappointments in the ALCS. In some ways, without Alomar there may not have been "Touch 'em all Joe!". Without Alomar there might not have been Blue Jays mania in the city of Toronto in the early 90s. Without Alomar, the Blue Jays would not be the Blue Jays. That's greatness right there.